Lincoln Highway Tavern Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing the menu at Lincoln Highway Tavern, a hidden gem nestled in Evanston, WY. This cozy establishment offers a welcoming atmosphere perfect for travelers and locals alike. Renowned for its exceptional wings that boast both size and flavor, the tavern's culinary offerings don’t stop there. Patrons rave about the 66 Buffalo Burger, with many proclaiming it a must-try, alongside equally enticing options like the brown and gold burger and the perfectly cooked sweet potato fries.
With a diverse selection of appetizers, including roasted Japanese chilies, guests can find something to satisfy every craving. The bar staff is exceptional, providing attentive service, creating a lively environment well-suited for watching sports or unwinding after a long day. Lincoln Highway Tavern is not just a place to dine; it's a community hub, promising delicious food and a memorable experience every visit.
Snacks & Starters
Golden Brown Delicious Fries
3/4 lb. of Fried Shoestring Spuds. No batter added. With "Pioneer" Fry Sauce
GBD's Smothered
Our GBD Fries smothered in our own Zonker Stout Gravy
Canadian Truck Stop Style GBD's
Smothered Fries topped with Melted Cheddar-Jack
Cheesed Off GBD's
Fries topped with Melted Cheddar-Jack and Bacon with our Dilly Ranch Dressing
Cheesed Off & Hot
Topped with our Homemade and Original "Chuck Box" Chili
THE Much-Discussed Chicken Wings (8)
Crispy Skin with no batter, flour, or cornstarch added. Buffalo (Mid-hot), Two Jacks BBQ, or Sticky-Sweet Teriyaki. Spicier Tingler (Hot) or Wendy (Very Hot) available (). Served with Carrots and Celery and our Dilly Ranch or Dad's Blue Cheese.
14 Wings
28 Wings
Home Made Chuck Box Chili- "The Big 'Un" w/ Grilled Cheese
Home Made Range-style Chili made with Braised Short Rib, Ground Beef, Home Made Chili Powder, Roasted Pasilla Chiles, Jalapenos, Onions, Bell Peppers, and both Red and Black Beans all simmered in our Braising Stock. 8 oz. topped with Cheddar-Jack and Onions, served with a Grilled Cheese.
Medium Chili
6 oz. topped with Cheddar-Jack and Onions, served with half a Grilled Cheese.
Small Chili
4 oz. topped with Cheddar Jack and Onions, served with Saltines.
In-Case-Mom's-Watching Salad
A simple side Salad of Mixed Green Lettuces, Arugula, Onions, Grape Tomatoes and your choice of Dilly Ranch, Dad's Blue Cheese, Home Made White Vinaigrette, or Home Made Balsamic Vinaigrette.
But-Mom-I'm-Really-Hungry Size
Double the size with a slab of Grilled Prmesan Sourdough, and, still, your choice of Dressing.
Why'd the Chicken Cross the A23?
Our Mixed Greens and Arugula tossed with Onions, Grape Tomatoes, Green Olives, and Crumbled Blue Cheese, topped with our Grilled and Sliced Tuscan Marinated Chicken Breast, House Made White Vinaigrette (yes you may substitute at no charge), and a slab of Grilled Parmesan Sourdough.
Why'd the Cow Just Stand There?
Mixed Greens and Arugula tossed with Onions, Grape Tomatoes, Candied Walnuts, and Crumbled Blue Cheese, topped with 8 oz. sliced of Beer-marinated USDA Sirloin grilled to your liking with Home Made Soy-Balsamic Dressing and a slab of Grilled Parmesan Sourdough.
Rabbit Food (Salads)
Wing Combos- all served with Carrots & Celery and your choice of our Dilly Ranch or Dad's Blue Cheese.
Wings & Fries
Half a dozen of our famous Crispy Skin Wings in your choice of Buffalo (Mid-Hot), Two Jacks BBQ, or Sticky-Sweet Teriyaki with our GBD Fries and "Pioneer" Fry Sauce.
Wings & a Salad
Half a dozen Wings with an ICMW Salad with your choice of Dilly Ranch, Dad's Blue Cheese, Home Made White Vinaigrette, or Home Made Soy-Balsamic Vinaigrette.
Wings & a Grilled Cheese
Half a dozen Wings with our Parmesan-dusted Grilled Cheese. If you'd like to customize your Grilled Cheese, please ask your server.
The Carnivore
Half a dozen Wings and 4 oz. of our Chuck Box Chili topped with Cheddar-Jack, and Onions. Served with Saltines.
The Megavore
Half a dozen Wings, 4 oz. of Chuck Box Chili, and a Beer-simmered, Grill-finished Johnsonville Brat. Sauerkraut and Spicy Brown Mustard on the side. Add Fireball Onions for .75.
The Full Spread
Half a dozen Wings, ICMW Salad, Fries, 4 oz. of Chuck Box Chili, and half a Parmesan-dusted Grilled Cheese.
A la Carte
A single Brat on a Bun with Sauerkraut and Spicy Brown on the side. Add Fireball Onions for .75.
Brat and Fries
A Brat with GBD Fries and "Pioneer" Fry Sauce.
Double Brats & Fries
Two Brats with Fries.
Game Day Stadium Brats- Johnsonville Brats simmered in Beer Broth and Grill-finished in the Bun with Sauerkraut and Spicy Brown on the side.
World Famous and Original Buffalo Joe (aka Sloppy Bill)
Buffalo Joe
Lean Ground locally-raised Bison simmered with Onions, Bell Peppers, and Jalapenos in our very own Whiskey Sloppy Sauce on a grilled Potato Bun topped with Flamin' Fun Yuns and Spicy-Sweet Pickles. Served with Fries. Add Cheddar-Jack for .75.
Old Timey Grilled Cheese
More gooey fun than the Bovine Snot Museum in Sidney! Slices of American Cheeses melted between two slices of Grilled Parmesan Sourdough. Add sliced Tomatoes on us. Add Bacon Crumbles or Roasted Green Chiles for .75. Add Laughing Cow Garlic-Herb Swiss for 1. Have it with Sharp Cheddar, Swiss, Smoky Provolone, or Pepper Jack for 1. Served with Fries and "Pioneer" Fry Sauce.
Double BLT
6 slices of premium Hardwood-smoked Bacon with, you guessed it Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo on grilled Sourdough. Served with Fries.
Oooh, Mommy! BLT
Our Double BLT, but with Chipotle Mayo and Fireball Onions. A real smoky Umami Bomb! Served with Fries.
Tavern Patty Melt
A slightly updated classic- our special blend of Ground Beef, Fireball Onions, and lots of Swiss melted between slices of Grilled Parmesan Sourdough. Served with Fries.
Tavern Bison Melt
Our Tavern Melt but made with delicious locally-raised Ground Bison.
Sourdough Sandwiches
The Heartland Steak Sandwich
Steak Sandwich
8 oz. of sliced USDA Beer-marinated Sirloin grilled to your liking on grilled Ciabatta with Garlic-Herb Swiss, Dill Aioli, and Arugula. Add Fireball Onions, no charge. Served with Fries.
Crazy Frickin' Kahuna
Teriyaki-glazed grilled Chicken Breast with premium Bacon, Pepper Jack, Grilled Pineapple, Yellow Onions, and Sriracha Mayo on a grilled Wheat Sub Roll.
Tuscan Damn Sun
Italian-marinated grilled Chicken Breast with fresh Leaf Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Rosemary-Dill Mayo on a Wheat Sub Roll.
Southwest By Far F!@#! East
Teriyaki-glazed grilled Chicken Breast with American Cheese, Roasted Green Chiles, fresh Leaf Lettuce, Spicy-Sweet Pickles, and our SWxFE Curry Mayo on a Wheat Sub Roll.
Fowl-Mouth Chicken Sandwiches- Served with Fries.
Tavern Burgers- choice of our house blend Ground Beef or locally-raised Bison. All served on grilled Sesame Seed Buns with Fries.
The Reg'lar
Fresh Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, and Dill Pickles. Add American Cheese on us.
The Reg'lar Bison
Same as above with a Locally-Raised Bison Patty.
The 66
A New Mexico Route 66-style Green Chile Cheeseburger with roasted Green Chiles, Fireball Onions, Smoky Provolone, and Spicy-Sweet Pickles.
The 66 Bison
THE Brown & Gold
For the ultimate Fan!!! Aged Cheddar, premium Bacon, Fireball Grilled Onions, Spicy-Sweet Pickles, Lettuce, Tomato, and smoky Chipotle Mayo.
THE Brown & Gold Bison
The Aloha!
Teriyaki-glazed patty with Jalapenos, Pepper Jack, grilled Pineapple, Flamin' Fun Yuns, and fiery Sriracha Mayo.
The Aloha! Bison
The Times Square "Coke" Habit
Decadent and rich with Sauteed Mushrooms, Swiss Cheese, and our own Pub Sauce. Lettuce, Tomato, and Onion on the side.
The Times Square "Coke" Habit Bison
End-of-the Road Chili Size
A West Coast favorite featuring our Chuck Box Chili, Cheddar Jack, and Onions.
End-of-the Road Chili Size Bison
Hand Pattied House Blend Beef
Locally-Raised Bison
Grilled Italian Herb or Teriyaki-marinated Chicken Breast
Sesame Seed Bun
No charge.
Sourdough
Potato Bun
Whole Wheat Sub Roll
Free Stuff
American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Dill Pickles, Mayo, Spicy Brown Mustard, Dijon Mustard, "Pioneer" Fry Sauce.
Call Shelf- .75 Each
Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Swiss, Provolone, Crumbled Blue Cheese, Flamin' Fun Yuns, Pub Sauce, Chipotle Mayo, Sriracha Mayo, SWxFE Mayo, Rosemary-Dill Mayo, Grilled Pineapple, Spicy-Sweet Pickles, Jalapenos, Roasted Green Chiles, Fireball Onions.
Top Shelf- 1 Each
Garlic-Herb Swiss, Two Jacks' BBQ Sauce, Buffalo Sauce, Sticky-Sweet Teriyaki Sauce, Zonker Stout Gravy.
Premium Hardwood-smoked Bacon
Sauteed Mushrooms
Sauteed with Garlic in Butter and White Wine.